Here it is! Blogtor’s personal countdown of his 50 favourite Doctor Who television stories, one a week till the big day in November 2013. Now, just to point out, this choice is purely my own. So don’t expect reasoned debate or objectivity. Or even the need to please every fan out there. This is my list, and I stand by it. I will also add that I’ve seen every Doctor Who story released (at least twice), so I feel like I know what I’m talking about. Anyway, enough chittle of the chattle, let’s begin…

First broadcast 6/5/2006 starring David Tennant

I remember back in, ooooo let me think, 2006 when it was announced that Steven “SteeMo” Moffat would be back to write another Doctor Who story, I was more than happy to see my fellow Scot back, though I did wonder if he’d be able to live up to his wonderful Ninth Doctor story, The Empty Child (at No. 38 in the countdown, chart fans). Thankfully, my wonderings underestimated the man’s talent.

Looking back, The Girl in the Fireplace remains as strong as ever with its emotional resonance, joie de vivre and brilliant science-fiction storytelling showing off Moffat at his absolute prime (AND it’s got time travel!).

David Tennant was in his stride by this point as The Tenth Doctor (after the fantastic double-header of Tooth & Claw and School Reunion), and gets to free himself of his TARDIS chums (Rose and Mickey) and teams up with companion-for-a-story, Madame de Pompadour (so beautifully played by Sophia Myles). Of course, there’s also the other companion, Arthur the “horse”, but let’s stick with the human cast for the time being.

The chemistry between Tennant and Myles was tangible, and their electricity drove the drama of the story tenfold, as we truly believed the connection between the two. There was so much at stake, not just for her (potentially about to die) but also for him, Reinette was clearly a special woman – letting her into his own mind was testimony to that. She intrigued him, visibly more so than most female characters (with the possible of exception of River Song and Joan Redfern – though he was human at the time). A great pity that the French beauty couldn’t have traveled with the Time Lord for some time as she had all the hall marks of a top notch TARDIS traveler.

And just look what was about to kill her, the creepy Clockwork Droids – another great Moffat invention. Like swans or prostitutes with gonorrhea, beautiful but deadly. The facelessness and impassive quality accentuate their menace but it’s the very fact that it’s their programming which makes them “killers”; it’s their destiny. And the sadness of their plight, despite the atrocities they committed, comes through – mirrored in the same destined journey for Reinette, and her journey with The Doctor. Acute writing from SteeMo.

There’s also some neat and typically wonderfully humorous lines from the Scottish writer: referring to the “time window” as a “magic door” (and so superbly delivered by Billie Piper); Moffat’s banana obsession (again, a top turn from Tennant as Drinky Doctor); and the repeated “Got some cowboys in here”. All marvelously light, juxtaposing with the dilemma at hand and the subtle horror of what actually happened on board the SS Madame de Pompadour.

Which brings me to one of the most affecting moments in Doctor Who‘s history, the reveal of the spaceship. If the death of Madame de Pompadour wasn’t enough (and it was bloody rough on the old emotions for Blogtor), the whole story’s heart is ripped apart with the solution to the mystery of the Clockwork Droids and their stalking of a woman in 18th century France; they were simply following misguided/broken programming. The whole situation was a simple mistake, with no one to blame. It was a solution The Doctor would never discover. 

The Girl in the Fireplace is a perfect one-off story that demonstrates the very best facets of Doctor Who; it’s a story that can be shown to “newbies” as an introduction and one us “oldies” can fully appreciate in all its romantically sci-fi, mirror-smashing style. I had to agree when I read Steven Moffat slightly lamenting that this tale would have made a great movie. It would have. A heart-breaking yet rambunctious film, that could only have come from the adventures of Gallifrey’s finest.

Regardless of perfect movie or not, we got a forty-five minute televisual slice of sheer heaven that ranks as the very best of Doctor Who. Thank you Steven.

Previous articleArchive Sydney Newman interview
Next articleThe Light At The End audio drama
Cameron K. McEwan
Cameron K McEwan was the first owner and site editor of Blogtor Who since its creation in May 2008 until Dec 2015. A lifelong Doctor Who fan, Cameron has also written two books, The Who’s Who of Doctor Who and Doctor Who: The Big Book of Lists, and directed a film all about Doctor Who fans throughout the years, Who’s Changing - An Adventure In Time With Fans. Cameron also contributes TV and film news and reviews to BBC Radio London, Metro, Digital Spy, New York Observer and Den of Geek. He lives in London with his one trousers.


  1. Where have these been? You haven't posted on of these in months. In fact, I think you were in the 30's last time.

  2. I agree with this choice – it's hard to pick a top Moffat episode but this would have to be up near the top. The Clockwork Droids are possibly his best invention, the production design is lavish – it's a beautiful episode – and the quiet horror is really effective. We can argue about the Rose problem with this one, as for some this episode really doesn't seem to fit with the Doctor and Rose's story throughout the rest of series 2, but as a stand-alone it's quite brilliant.

    I've come back to this one more times than I can count, it's so easy to get swept away by the humour and the romance of it all. Moffat has revisited a number of the tropes seen here in his tenure as show-runner (the Doctor being a little girl's imaginary friend etc), but for me this is the best and most elegant use of them.

    Beautiful 🙂


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.